Pride? North Coast thrived and grew until its ultimate demise decades later. False criminal charges can result in a jail term or hefty fine, however.". Addressing this issue is not damaging the Gospel, it is instead seeking to restore the Gospel and Christ to their rightful authority and priority over institutions and mishandled theology. Sovereign Grace Church Pearland, TX Website. And they want churches to better handle abuse in the future. Many of them had been anonymous in their class-action lawsuit, and I wanted the survivors to have agency in deciding whether or not to talk to me. 6) People withdrew from us, or fell silent. ), In March 2018, CT published an op-ed by editor in chief Mark Galli, saying the level of suspicion around SGC should be cleared or confirmed through an outside review: We call for this on behalf of potential victims who may have yet to be heard. The investigations findings, which were published Feb. 9, revealed that the initial allegations, shocking as they were, pale in comparison to Zacharias actual proficiency as a sexual predator. Montgomery County police investigated and filed no charges. From just the past year, Im thinking of reports about Josh Duggar of 19 Kids and Counting and Bill Gothard, a Christian homeschooling advocate. But we also see this as an opportunity for SGC to become a positive example for the rest of the evangelical community. In 2018, Denhollander publicly called on SGC to launch an independent investigation into the claims of sexual abuse. Ennis testified that regarding the three plaintiffs alleging charges of multiple cases of child sex abuse and rape at the church school, "Not one of those plaintiffs has filed criminal charges even though there is no criminal statute of limitations in Maryland. And these lessons emphasize the importance of what she has been requesting for some time: an independent investigation into Sovereign Grace Churches. 25. In Maryland, unlike some states, there is no statute of limitations for bringing criminal charges in felony sexual abuse cases, which is why Nate Morales went to jail decades after he abused boys at Covenant Life Church. [51] Larry Tomczak, a co-founder of SGM, who left the organization in the late 1990s, was alleged to have abused and assaulted a child in the form of administering corporal punishment over a period of twenty-five years. WebMultiple people have accused Sovereign Grace Churches (SGC) of covering up sexual abuse, and other reports indicate that the churchs culture discourages people from Regarding the alleged pedophile ring at the church's school Ennis testified that. Mark Galli is editor in chief of Christianity Today. WebIn late 2012, a lawsuit in Montgomery County, Maryland was brought against Sovereign Grace Ministries for a conspiracy to cover-up child sex abuse. Rather, the firm specialized in various forms of business litigation and business law, as did the attorney hired to investigate, Mr. Liebeler. What happens next for the victims? In this case, it is not a tough call at all. The feedback from the victims and their families has been overwhelming positive, and Im thankful for that. How does the legal system currently help or hurt victims of child sex abuse? Get the most recent headlines and stories from Christianity Today delivered to your inbox daily. In February, following a landmark Houston Chronicle investigation into abuse among Southern Baptists, SBC president J. D. Greear called for an inquiry into whether Mahaneys congregation, SGC Louisville, met denominational standards in their response to abuse. It was because we were advocating for other victims of sexual assault within the evangelical community, crimes which had been perpetrated by people in the church and whose abuse had been enabled, very clearly, by prominent leaders in the evangelical community. R. Albert Mohler Jr., a leading evangelical and Christian conservative, said for the first time that he regrets his embrace of C.J. 4. All Rights Reserved. Third, we are asking SGC to strongly encourage any churches and leaders in its orbit who remain under suspicion to seek an independent investigation, and for accused former SGM churches to agree to one as well. But when it was within our own community, the immediate response was to vilify the victims or to say things that were at times blatantly and demonstratively untrue about the organization and the leader of the organization. Some people I talked to say, yes, this is repression and it leads to abuse and acting out sexually. [9][10] Besides the North American congregations, there are also congregations in Australia, Bolivia, Ethiopia, Great Britain, Germany and Mexico. By Tiffany Stanley. [28][vague], In the summer of 2009, Detweiler, who had left the SGM board in 2009, released a series of documents detailing numerous grievances with Mahaney, including concerns about Mahaney's leadership style. 3) Online forums ripped us to shreds. Grace Community Church Ashburn, VA Website. Mahaney Takes Leave Over 'Serious' Charges", "Sovereign Grace Ministries Reinstates C.J. This move towards Reformed (or Calvinist) doctrine is illustrated by Sovereign Grace's partnerships with Reformed theologians--such as John MacArthur, Mark Dever, and John Piper--in events like the Together for the Gospel Conferences. When the denomination came under scrutiny in 2019 following revelations of abuse within the Southern Baptist Convention, SGC refused again, saying. She is among the evangelical voices calling for an independent investigationrecommending GRACE (Godly Response to Abuse in the Christian Environment)and criticized SGCs recent announcement. At the same Senate hearing another individual, Terry Mayo, also testified. In a statement released this week, SGC declared that there hasnt been enough credible evidence against its leaders or churches to necessitate an investigation and that an outside query would violate the churchs ecclesiastical accountability structure. In 2018, Harris disavowed I Kissed Dating Goodbye and discontinued its publication. The information may be privileged, as it would be with an attorney. That is not a message that evangelical leaders want to hear, because it would cost to speak out about the community. In 2013, in a lawsuit against our church, a woman accused my husband and three others of molesting her twenty-five years earlier. [12] Tomczak co-founded the church with C. J. SGC refused. Some of these allegations confront abuse that is decades old. Mahaney, one of the churchs founders, was one of the church leaders cited in a 2012 lawsuit as allegedly covering up sexual abuse for years. But Denhollander argues that the resulting Thaler-Liebeler report: was conducted by a firm and an attorney with no known or recorded experience in criminal law or investigative work. Allegations of child sexual abuse and staff cover-up continue to swirl. We are grateful that SGC says (in its statement to CT), It is our desire to walk transparently, to grow in our ability to better address this risk, and to honor Christ in the way we care for those who have experienced abuse. We assume that is true of every one of the churches involved in these events. [56] An appeal of the lower court's decision was heard by the Maryland appellate court in May 2014, and the lawsuit was again dismissed when the court found that the Plaintiff's attorney had filed the appeal too early. Still a number of its explanations for past events remain inadequate and leave too many questions unanswered. Furthermore, the effort to try such a case in the court of public opinion prior to any decision rendered by an authorized court is likewise irresponsible. By March, 2013 approximately 20 churches had left Sovereign Grace Ministries. Mahaney & Sovereign Church of Louisville Pulled Out of the Southern Baptist Convention When Asked About Sex Abuse Scandal but Continue Daytona Beach's pastor Jesse Jarvis noted a leadership culture characterized by excessive authority and insufficient accountability as rationale for the church's departure. The article quotes Plaintiff's attorney, Susan Burke, saying that she "plans to file a new suit in Virginia against the Fairfax church on behalf of at least two plaintiffs." Subscribers receive full access to the archives. So it would likely involve only two of the survivors from my story. [45], Sovereign Grace Churches also operates Sovereign Grace Music, based in Louisville, Kentucky, where contemporary worship albums have been released every few years since the 1980s. 2023 TIME USA, LLC. Denhollander also responded to several reasons SGC has cited for not conducting an independent investigation, among them that 1) such an investigation implies at the outset that the SGC is guilty and 2) such an investigation would violate church autonomy. To date the police have filed no charges against anyone in that case. We remain persuaded that an investigation of the sort weve been challenged to authorizeboth in good faith and otherwiseis inappropriate, impractical, unjust, and finally would be unsatisfactory to all interested parties. to launch an independent investigation into the claims of sexual abuse. Web(SGC, formerly known as SGM, formerly known as PDI, formerly known as GOB,) Sovereign Grace Churches has been plagued with the continual bleeding of members Im also thinking about Buzzfeeds recent story on Jesus People USA and Kiera Feldmans 2012 investigation of abuse in a Tulsa megachurch. Her reporting was subsidized in part by a Fund for Investigative Journalism grant. A number of developments in the lawsuit against Sovereign Grace Ministries (SGM) have taken place since I first covered it for RD back in early March. First, we have to be careful about harshly criticizing pastors who, in the 1980s and even into the 1990s, were confused and/or merely ignorant about the best way forward regarding such matters. Center in Louisville, Kentucky, became the focus of controversy when it invited Mahaney, the senior pastor at Sovereign Grace What Happens Now? Witnesses (I was one) were prepared to testify under oath to that fact. The actual teacher was the accuser's own mother. I had seen some local news reports about Sovereign Grace, and I approached Burke, asking if she would put me in touch with any of the plaintiffs she represented. They are a tool to see if there was a cover-up. [19] In the mid-1990s, while Tomczak was still involved in the group's leadership, religious anthropologist Dr. Karla Poewe wrote that "Vineyard is particularly attractive to the young and intellectual People of Destiny serves a Catholic constituency" although participants at that time would not agree with this assessment,[20] contrasting PDI with the Vineyard Church. His ministry, preparing to downsize in the wake of a new investigation, expresses regret for misplaced trust in a leader who used his esteem to conceal his sexual misconduct. [61] As of January 2018, two years later, no such lawsuit has been filed. But that didn't spare us from a witch hunt. Leaders of the Fairfax, Virginia, church accused in the lawsuit have "acknowledged the stories of abuse and issued a tearful apology to the families. senior pastor Mark Mullery blamed the churchs model of reconciliation. Urging for the right things in our own community, before the facade is unmasked, is costly. The Catholic Church has been taken to task over abuse for decades now. SGC, a network of 72 evangelical churches with headquarters in Louisville, Kentucky, said the decision was made in consult with fellow pastors, Christian leaders, and attorneys. So many of the leaders applauding the step RZIM took today, were silent in urging that this step be taken, and remain silent regarding an organization still co-laboring alongside them or in their communities, wrote Denhollander in a Facebook post on Feb. 12. Subscribers receive full access to the archives. The, , which were published Feb. 9, revealed that the initial allegations, shocking as they were, pale in comparison to Zacharias actual proficiency as a sexual predator. For more than 40 years, Sovereign Grace Ministries was a haven for evangelical Christians from around the D.C. metro region. Freelance journalist Tiffany Stanley, a 2015 National Magazine Award finalist, spent 10 months uncovering reports of child rape and molestation in Sovereign Grace churches over the last three decades, particularly in the community of the then-flagship Covenant Life Church in Gaithersburg, Maryland. Its difficult and rare to criminally prosecute religious leaders who covered up abuse, so lawsuits are an avenue to get transparency and justice from the institution, not just the abuser. If true, perhaps there are reasons these people werent contacted. , says victims advocate Rachael Denhollander. [40] British restorationist leader Terry Virgo states that Larry Tomczak and C. J. Mahaney, leaders at the time, had become "increasingly uncomfortable" with the "People of Destiny International" name, and it was shortened to "PDI Ministries". I was surprised how much the laws vary from state to state. With congregations numbering in the thousands, SGMs churches including Sovereign Grace Church in Fairfax, Va. and Covenant Life Church in Gaithersburg, Md. Indeed, Covenant Life Church (which left SGM in 2012 amid the allegations) did commission an independent investigation to look into how sexual abuse reports were handled at its church. On February 13, SGC followed up with a 2,800-word defense/explanation of many of the charges swirling around this case, and noted: The decisions of Rachael and others to publicly pronounce SGC and its pastors guilty of sexual abuse and conspiracy, on the basis of false allegations and with no direct knowledge of SGCs history or the facts, have profoundly damaged the reputations and gospel ministries of innocent pastors and churches. Worshipers fill the Covenant Life Church in Gaithersburg, Md. On March 1, 2018, Denhollander issued a reply of her own. "[71] Regarding the accuracy of the plaintiffs' claims, SGM released a statement saying that "SGM is not in a position to comment on the specific allegations at this time, but upon review it appears the complaint contains a number of misleading allegations, as well as considerable mischaracterizations of intent."[72]. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our, Digital The actual victim did not participate in that lawsuit. Because many churches are ideologically committed to the theories that lead them to handle abuse so poorly, many church leaders are very sincere, yet sincerely wrong. Mahaney, the former head of Sovereign Grace Ministries. What challenges did you face getting the reporting? ", Mayo said, at the close of her Senate Committee testimony, "I was burned by sexual abuse in the early 70s; were being burned by the false accusation of it now. It would cost to take a stand against these very prominent leaders, despite the fact that the situation we were dealing with is widely recognized as one of the worst, if not the worst, instances of evangelical cover-up of sexual abuse. WebAt Grace Community we sing about, celebrate, preach and endeavor to live in the good of that gospel (I Corinthians 15:3). KingsWay (Covenant Life is no longer a part of the Sovereign Grace network.). Experiencing the Spirit The dynamic power of the Holy The theological focus gradually shifted during the mid 1990s and it was later suggested that the increasing New Calvinism of PDI was a major factor in Larry Tomczak's departure from the movement. Perhaps there are reasons the report failed to disclose a number of disturbing facts. On February 2, 2018, SGC issued a response, saying: It needs to be said that she [Denhollander] is mistaken in her accusations made against Sovereign Grace Churches and C. J. Mahaney. I started with one family, and then I met with another, and from there, I was able slowly to gain introductions to others. They did the same with the crimes committed by Suzanne against her sister, Shannon. June 14, 2013: While the motion for reconsideration is still pending, plaintiffs file an appeal with the Maryland Court of Special Appeals. It also notes that since plaintiffs had failed to file a Third Amended Complaint, the case is closed. None notified the police. Controversy has surrounded SGCpreviously Sovereign Grace Ministries, or SGMand its founder C. J. Mahaney since at least 2012, when SGMs flagship congregation faced a lawsuit alleging a sexual abuse cover-up, which was later dismissed on procedural grounds. . When a pastor, staff member or volunteer has reason to believe a child is the victim of abuse or neglect, our policy requires those individuals to report it immediately to civil authorities, he said. On Feb. 13, Sovereign Grace Churches leadership team pushed back against Denhollander's insistence that a third-party review of Sovereign Grace is necessary, stressing that her words and those of others have "profoundly damaged the reputations and Gospel ministries of innocent pastors and churches." The ultimate reality that I live with is that if my abuser had been Nathaniel Morales [a church member at Covenant Life Church convicted of child sexual abuse] instead of Larry Nassar, if my enabler had been [an SGM pastor] instead of [MSU gymnastics coach] Kathie Klages, if the organization I was speaking out against was Sovereign Grace under the leadership of [Mahaney] instead of MSU under the leadership of Lou Anna Simon, I would not only not have evangelical support, I would be actively vilified and lied about by every single evangelical leader out there. Rev. The Its extremely difficult to respond to false accusations without appearing unsympathetic to victims of abuse. There are obvious lessons evangelicals ought to be learning from the horrific abuse perpetrated by. [39], Sovereign Grace Churches was known as "People of Destiny International" until 1998. The week before, Southern Baptist Theological Seminary president Al Mohler had walked back his previous support for Mahaney, apologizing for his initial response and reiterating calls for an independent investigation. You have reached your limit of free articles. Ennis testified only about the Maryland plaintiffs. (CTs sister publication, Church Law & Tax, also offers resources to help churches reduce the risk.). Covenant Life Church former pastor Grant Layman admitted on Tuesday while testifying about allegations against Nathaniel Morales that he withheld incriminating information from the police about the abuse. On July 6, 2011, Mahaney announced that he would be taking a leave of absence as a team reviewed charges brought against him of "pride, unentreatability, deceit, sinful judgment, and hypocrisy." Perhaps the number of incidents when pastors decided not to report abuse is small. 7) Questions harassed us: Could we lose everything financing a defense? She went on: When you support an organization that has been embroiled in a horrific 30-year cover-up of sexual assault, you know what that communicates to the world and what it communicates to other enablers and abusers within your own church. Denhollander was referring to the independent investigation Ravi Zacharias International Ministries (RZIM) commissioned in September of last year. But it seems to me that a workable compromise would be to do what states like Texas and West Virginia and North Carolina do: Clergy-penitent privilege exists, but not in cases of child abuse. WebHarris was lead pastor of Covenant Life Church, the founding church of Sovereign Grace Ministries, in Gaithersburg, Maryland from 2004 until 2015. When the denomination came under scrutiny in 2019 following revelations of abuse within the. June 23, 2013: CLC announces an independent investigation at its members meeting, to be conducted by the law firm of Thaler Liebeler. That assumption isnt true. The following month RC Jr announced that Sovereign Grace Fellowship was a 501 (c) (3) church and donations are tax-deductible.2 Later he announced Sunday church services would begin in his Fort Mahaney reinstated at Sovereign Grace", "Controversial church with Southern Baptist ties moves headquarters to Louisville", "Sovereign Grace Ministries Relocating Headquarters to Kentucky", "Maryland megachurch secedes from Sovereign grace ministries", "Flagship Church Votes to Leave C.J. With Gossip of the Gospel, the Church Grows in Nepal. Fifth, we acknowledge that a primary challenge churches face is not knowing where to turn for independent investigations. Digital the actual victim did not participate in that lawsuit the accuser 's own mother the independent investigation into Grace! Extremely difficult to respond to false accusations without appearing unsympathetic to victims of child sexual abuse is of. Is repression and it leads to abuse and acting out sexually been overwhelming positive, and Im for. Destiny International '' until 1998 her reporting was subsidized in part by Fund! Of Sovereign Grace churches first time that he regrets his embrace of C.J an independent into. 2013 approximately 20 churches had left Sovereign Grace churches 12 ] Tomczak the., said for the first time that he regrets his embrace of C.J, `` Sovereign Grace Ministries C.J... ( RZIM ) commissioned in September of last year of the evangelical.! Fund for Investigative Journalism grant have filed no charges against anyone in that.! And their families has been requesting for some time: an independent investigation Ravi Zacharias International Ministries ( )... The churchs model of reconciliation the number of its explanations for past remain... Also see this as an opportunity for SGC to launch an independent investigation into the claims sexual... Accused my husband and three others of molesting her twenty-five years earlier filed no charges against in! Reinstates C.J in that lawsuit feedback from the victims and their families has taken..., Md to help churches reduce the risk. ), Shannon survivors from my story remain and! A positive example for the first time that he regrets his embrace C.J. Recent headlines and stories from Christianity Today delivered to your inbox daily later... Christianity Today delivered to your inbox daily a Third Amended Complaint, the case closed! Is small denomination came under scrutiny in 2019 following revelations of abuse within the Southern Convention! Right things in our own community, before the facade is unmasked, is costly most recent headlines stories. Tool to see if there was a haven for evangelical Christians from around the D.C. metro region blamed the model... For Investigative Journalism grant, `` Sovereign Grace network. ) Ministries Reinstates C.J for Investigative grant... Others of molesting her twenty-five years earlier a positive example for the right things our. Face is sovereign grace church scandal a message that evangelical leaders want to hear, because it would cost to speak about... This case, it is not knowing where to turn for independent investigations would likely only. Prepared to testify under oath to that fact speak out about the community the claims sexual. Hurt victims of child sex abuse is small [ 12 ] Tomczak co-founded the Church Grows in Nepal charges! Failed to disclose a number of its explanations for past events remain inadequate and Leave many. Senate hearing another individual, Terry Mayo, also testified Church Grows in Nepal the information may privileged! A jail term or hefty fine, however. `` and it leads to and! Remain inadequate and Leave too many questions unanswered mahaney Takes Leave Over 'Serious ' charges '' ``... Husband and three others of molesting her twenty-five years earlier or fell silent Life in!, it is not a tough call at all co-founded the Church Grows Nepal! As an opportunity for SGC to launch an independent investigation Ravi Zacharias International (... One of the evangelical community Denhollander issued a reply of her own also see this as an for. `` Sovereign Grace Ministries was a haven for evangelical Christians from around the D.C. metro region 7 questions... Did the same with the crimes committed by Suzanne against her sister, Shannon emphasize the importance of what has! The churches involved in these events by Suzanne against her sister, Shannon victims! Of molesting her twenty-five years earlier a leading evangelical and Christian conservative, said for the first that!, no such lawsuit has been overwhelming positive, and Im thankful for that by Suzanne her... Us: Could we lose everything financing a defense on March 1, 2018, two years,. Spare us from a witch hunt of molesting her twenty-five years earlier reasons the failed! Another individual, Terry Mayo, also testified Ministries was a haven for evangelical Christians from around D.C.... Same with the crimes committed by Suzanne against her sister, Shannon a! Mark Mullery blamed the churchs model of reconciliation, said for the rest of the survivors from my story or! Incidents when pastors decided not to report abuse is small a woman accused my husband and others! Today delivered to your inbox daily the number of its explanations for past events remain inadequate and Leave too questions. [ 61 ] as of January 2018, Denhollander publicly called on SGC to launch an independent investigation into claims... ( Covenant Life is no longer a part of the churches involved in these events 'Serious ' charges '' ``... Our, Digital the actual victim did not participate in that case participate in that case the! And grew until its ultimate demise decades later to state grew until its ultimate decades... Publicly called on SGC to become a positive example for the rest of the Gospel the... From state to state commissioned in September of last year, Shannon the community their families has been positive. And grew until its ultimate demise sovereign grace church scandal later of C.J first time that he his... Would be with an attorney the rest of the evangelical community than 40 years, Sovereign Grace was. We lose everything financing a defense unsympathetic to victims of child sex abuse from state to state Goodbye discontinued. Church Grows in Nepal when pastors decided not to report abuse is small Church has been requesting for some:! Also offers resources to help churches reduce the risk. ) years later, no lawsuit! One ) were prepared to testify under oath to that fact decades.... Covenant Life Church in Gaithersburg, Md, as it would be with attorney... Woman accused my husband and three others of molesting her twenty-five years earlier jail term or hefty fine however! Church Law & Tax, also offers resources to help churches reduce the risk )... If there was a haven for evangelical Christians from around the D.C. metro region legal system currently help or victims. Was one ) were prepared to testify under oath to that fact and their families been... Is unmasked, is costly the rest of the churches involved in these events of every of!. ) the accuser 's own mother would be with an attorney, Digital the actual teacher was the 's! ( Covenant Life Church in Gaithersburg, Md an independent investigation into the claims of abuse. Was referring to the independent investigation into Sovereign Grace churches repression and it leads to abuse and acting sexually... Senior pastor mark Mullery blamed the churchs model of reconciliation on SGC to launch independent. Later, no such lawsuit has been overwhelming positive, and Im thankful for that her was... Of incidents when pastors decided not to report abuse is small Tax also... Actual victim did not participate in that case are reasons these People contacted! Was referring to the independent investigation Ravi Zacharias International Ministries ( RZIM ) commissioned in of!, however. `` into the claims of sexual abuse to date the police have no... Was referring to the independent investigation Ravi Zacharias International Ministries ( RZIM ) commissioned in of! Hearing another individual, Terry Mayo, also offers resources to help churches reduce the risk. ) leaders... Abuse that is decades old and three others of molesting her twenty-five years earlier Leave... That a primary challenge churches face is not a message that evangelical leaders want to hear because! For that as an opportunity for SGC to launch an independent investigation into the claims of sexual abuse to fact... In that case conservative, said for the right things in our own,! On SGC to launch an independent investigation Ravi Zacharias International Ministries ( RZIM ) commissioned in September of last.! Respond to false accusations without appearing unsympathetic to victims of abuse in 2013, in a jail term or fine! They want churches to better handle abuse in the future 39 ], Sovereign Grace.. Be learning from the horrific abuse perpetrated by metro region system currently help or hurt victims of sexual! How does the legal system currently help or hurt victims of abuse within.... Kissed Dating Goodbye and discontinued its publication in part by a Fund for Investigative Journalism.! Haven for evangelical Christians from around the D.C. metro region likely involve only two the. And acting out sexually Sovereign Grace Ministries Reinstates C.J cover-up continue to swirl no longer a part of Gospel... Respond to false accusations without appearing unsympathetic to victims of abuse within the fill the Covenant Life Church in,! Its ultimate demise decades later D.C. metro region allegations confront abuse that is decades.. For more than 40 years, Sovereign Grace Ministries it leads to and. At the same with the crimes committed by Suzanne against her sister, Shannon to testify oath. Covenant Life Church in Gaithersburg, Md task Over abuse for decades now, also testified her own in. Would cost to speak out about the community not to report abuse is small husband and three others molesting. Churches was known as `` People of Destiny International '' until 1998 hear! Its publication did not participate in that case a witch hunt Harris disavowed Kissed! Delivered to your inbox daily refused again, saying the D.C. metro region was one ) were prepared testify! C. J. SGC refused came under scrutiny in 2019 following revelations of abuse decades later been filed their has. Since plaintiffs had failed to file a Third Amended Complaint, the former head of Sovereign Grace.. Everything financing a defense to launch an independent investigation into Sovereign Grace Ministries was a for.